Skip to content

Case studies

Real pull requests from open-source LLM apps, replayed through evalship: what their own eval checks said, and what evalship caught.

Replay ponytail's setup →

Catches a regression from a prompt cut

HolmesGPT is an open-source SRE agent. Its #1452 commented out parts of its prompt to see which ones mattered.

Read the HolmesGPT case study →

github.com/HolmesGPT/holmesgpt/pull/1452

HolmesGPT's eval check

Passed

It reports results but never fails the build.

evalship

Blocks the merge

162_get_runbooks fails after passing all 230 of its runs that month.

Spots a retired grading model

Prefect's MCP server gives AI assistants tools for Prefect workspaces. Its #200 fixed two of them.

Read the Prefect case study →

github.com/PrefectHQ/prefect-mcp-server/pull/200

Prefect's eval report

14 failed

Shown as 14 new failures against main.

evalship

14 couldn't run

The model that grades them had been retired and returned a 404, so none was graded.

See what evalship finds in your evals

Ask your coding agent: Claude Code Codex Cursor GitHub Copilot

Set up https://evalship.com/setup.md